Interview with an energy vampire

Enfants Riches Déprimés by © Cameron McCool

Data centres can't be contacted for comment—they are constructed, not conscious. Even so, computing facilities have recently been (understandably) referred to as energy vampires. That may be true, but anthropomorphising tech infrastructure can jumble lines of critical enquiry. Gothic literature helps us untangle and redirect our questions.

Interview with the Vampire traces a talk between protagonist Louis de Pointe du Lac and journalist Daniel Molloy¹. Uniquely, author Anne Rice puts her vampire in a position of narrative vulnerability, subverting the genre's literary conventions. We can't chat with data centres, but we can prep an interview for those pushing proposals. This exercise illuminates the criticality of consequential community participation, while also readying us for dialogue.


What do data centres feed on?

Enfants Riches Déprimés by © Cameron McCool

“The blood is the life," antagonist R. M. Renfield declares in Bram Stoker's Dracula². For data centres, energy and water are the life; the resources they must feed on to survive. We've been catering to theses facilities for decades now, the digital systems we now rely on would not be possible without them. Yet the rapid expansion of the sector raises urgent questions³. As the 'Energy Vampires: The AI data centres draining Australia' report articulates⁴:

"Australia is in the midst of a feverish data centre boom. From a standing start, billions of dollars are now pouring into a massive pipeline of proposed new data centres, of unprecedented size, being built at incredible speed in our suburbs." The situation extends beyond suburbia to regional Australia, however, with regulators now "sounding the alarm over the dizzying scale of energy and water needed to feed these hungry facilities."

Appetites will vary based on the scale of centres, however all tech infrastructure will need to "run all day, every day, to process, store, and manage digital data." As Climate Council reports⁵, "the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) expects data centre energy demand in the NEM to increase seven-fold within the next decade." Then there's the thirst. Based on energy demand forecasts, it's estimated that "the industry’s water demand will [also] increase around 7x over the next decade."


Why do we need hyperscale tech infrastructure?

If honesty was a law, data centre developers would voluntarily share the purpose, energy, and emissions impacts of individual facilities⁴. Yet given the rapid pace the industry has set, there's been little time to demand such transparency. As spelled out in the Energy Vampire report:

"The frenzied rollout of AI data centres in Australia is rushing through massive new projects, which will derail Australia’s energy transition unless the government urgently intervenes." Broadly (and vaguely) speaking, CBRE believes⁶ that the accelerated demand for computing capacity is driven "hyperscale cloud growth, the rapid adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) workloads, and corporate upgrades from legacy facilities." Yet the specific purpose for the additional data centre load remains a mystery. In the words of Ketan Joshi⁷:

"What does it mean for a data centre to expand its energy hunger? Who’s benefiting from that? Why is it considered rude to ask, in the midst of an urgent energy transition and and a crippling fossil fuel crisis?" These are all very valid questions, but it's hard to know who to ask. To date, "the data centre lobby has resisted attempts at regulation," Joe Rafalowicz—Head of Climate and Energy at Greenpeace Australia Pacific—says⁴. This is why the non-profit is "calling for a moratorium on new data centres" until appropriate regulations and safeguards are properly developed.

"And no vampire here has discourse with God or with the devil!" Louis de Pointe du Lac exclaims in Rice's novel¹. So far, few of us have had meaningful discourse with developers; that must change. As Rafalowicz writes⁴: "if we as Australians are to devote our finite land, water and clean energy to the operation of data centres, we are entitled to ask: 'what for?'"


Who benefits from the data centre boom?

"Initially, the internet was celebrated as a medium of boundless liberty," philosopher Byung-Chul Han writes⁸. "As it turned out, such euphoria was an illusion. Today, unbounded freedom and communication are switching over into total control and surveillance"

This sentiment helps us think critically about the sudden expansion of tech infrastructure. According to Data Centres Australia⁹, "sustainable data centre development will drive economic activity and employment - with a further opportunity for Australia to export AI compute delivering additional benefits." Yet, as the Energy Vampires report articulates⁴: "the actual functions served by data centres in the modern era remain extremely unclear." Simply put: we can't be sure who the sector's growth will ultimately serve ongoing.

As Han observes, the liberty promised by the internet has been impeded by digital surveillance. The lucrativeness of data centres may also compromise our quality of life, impacting communities and the environment at an emotional and material level. "Evil is always possible. And goodness is eternally difficult," Rice writes, words that teach us to think critically about suspiciously fast-tracked infrastructure proposals.

"Australia is not a playground for Big Tech corporations," Rafalowicz insists. We owe it to ourselves, and our ancestors, to proceed with caution. "While rare, there are growing examples of data centre development that prioritise democratic governance, the needs of local communities, and the minimisation of the consumption of local resources such as energy and water." If we demand a moratorium on data centres, we'll have more time to secure interviews with the makers of energy vampires.

"'Wait, wait!' said the boy in a welter of excitement. 'The tape is almost gone. I have to turn it over,'" Rice writes, describing a critical moment in the dialogue of her novel. "The vampire watched patiently as he changed it." To dream futures collectively, we must embody and strive forever towards such forbearance.